If you’ve been unsuccessful on the CPA Common Final Examination (CFE), you’re in far more common company than most people realize. Having coached CPA candidates for years, we’ve seen just how many different paths lead to the Canadian CPA designation, and plenty of them include more than one CFE attempt.
That’s why we sat down again with GCPA alum Rachael, who passed the CFE on her third and final attempt. What makes her story valuable isn’t the unsuccessful results. It’s how she worked through them, adjusted her approach, and kept going.
Watch the full conversation on YouTube
Rachael’s CFE Timeline
- Attempt 1 (May): Unsuccessful, Decile 1. She did not clear Level 3 (depth in her role, Assurance) and also fell short on Management Accounting at Level 2.
- Attempt 2 (September, immediately after): Unsuccessful again, Decile 1, this time on Level 1. By her own estimate, she was one or two questions away.
- Attempt 3: Registered for May, then chose to defer to September. She passed, and cleared every area.
Two Decile 1 results in a row. As Rachael put it, it felt like “a cruel, cruel lesson.” But it wasn’t the end of her story.
Coming Close Twice
Rachael received her first results while on a family vacation. She gave herself time to feel it, then decided to go straight into the September rewrite with a focused sprint: review what she knew, dig deeper into Assurance, and tighten up her time management.
The second result, arriving just before Christmas, hit differently. “It felt like pure exhaustion,” she shared. She had gone in with hope and a “what’s the worst that could happen?” mindset, and then it felt like the worst had happened.
Her takeaway, and the one she most wants other candidates to hear: there is no direct line and no perfect journey. You take each thing as it comes.
You Don’t Have to Relearn Everything
When Rachael restarted in February, she felt lost. Should she redo everything? Did she really know anything at all?
The answer was no, she didn’t need to redo everything. Looking at the stacks of cases, Integrations, and Practice Cases from her earlier attempts, she realized that what actually needed restudying was much smaller than it looked. “It’s more going to be the mind game and the time game,” she said. The real work was deciding what to review and how.
Knowing When to Wait
After studying through the spring for a May rewrite, Rachael made the difficult decision to defer. She had been doing all the right things, but she was mentally exhausted. Work was heavy following a major ERP implementation, and when she told her family she was stepping back, their response was simple: they had seen it too, and they supported her.
Today, the CFE is offered only in September, so candidates rewriting will have a longer runway by default. Rachael’s advice for using that time well:
- Build up gradually. Push through spring and summer, then start easing off in August.
- Protect the final 10 days. Before the exam, shift to light review only: notes, cue cards, good sleep, and whatever helps you decompress. Even if you’re working until the week of the exam, find a way to shift gears mentally.
- Trust that you won’t forget. Many candidates worry that slowing down means losing ground. Rachael found the opposite. That breathing room is what let her walk in with the mental capacity to perform.
What Rachael Did Differently the Third Time
Better pacing. On her first attempt, she tried to do too much, including writing three Day 3 cases back to back to simulate exam day. By the third attempt, she recognized that she already knew she could sit for five hours and work through roughly 21 Assessment Opportunities across three cases. She didn’t need to prove that to herself again.
Trusting what she knew. A first-time writer often walks in wondering whether they know anything. A rewriter has results that show exactly what they do and don’t know. “The idea of going into Day 3 and knowing nothing is just not the truth,” Rachael said.
Working with a coach who fit her needs. Rachael worked with Mallory, a coach she found through Gevorg CPA, throughout her program. For Rachael, Mallory was an accountability partner and someone to share her thoughts, fears, and frustrations with. Other candidates may need a tougher, more directive style. Her advice is to find the right fit, much like choosing a therapist, and to remember that coaching doesn’t have to be a six-month commitment. A handful of sessions over the summer can help you refine your approach.
Taking accommodations seriously. Rachael shared that she could have applied for exam accommodations and chose not to, and looking back, she wishes she had. With only September sittings, a first-time rewrite no longer leaves you without time to apply. If you need an accommodation, plan ahead and apply. No one else needs to know, and you deserve every chance of success.
Don’t Just Repeat the Same Preparation
If you do the same thing again, how can you expect a different result? Before rewriting, be honest with yourself:
- Did you follow your study schedule?
- Did you have an accountability partner, study buddy, or study network?
- Were your time management and case strategy working?
At the same time, avoid over-rotating. Failing in one area doesn’t mean you should study only that area. You still need coverage everywhere, with extra focus where your results point.
Read Your Results Carefully
Rachael’s first results surprised her. With a background in audit and risk, she expected Assurance to come easily. With years in finance, she assumed Management Accounting would make intuitive business sense. Instead, she did better in Financial Reporting than in either. Her lesson: set aside your assumptions about which areas are “easy” for you, and look at what the numbers actually say.
Equally important, the areas you passed were not luck. “Your passes were not luck. You did what you needed to do,” Rachael said.
The CFE passing profile is publicly available, but it isn’t simple. Unlike a university exam with a single percentage, the CFE is assessed across four levels, and candidates often misread them. For example:
- Passing Level 4 (breadth) does not mean you passed Day 3.
- Passing Level 3 (depth in your role) does not mean you passed Day 2.
Misinterpreting your results can send your preparation in the wrong direction. Take the time to understand them properly, whether with us, a mentor, or another trusted resource, before you build your rewrite plan.
And a word on online forums: be careful with Reddit threads. People aren’t necessarily lying, but they are sharing their own perception, often without the full picture. Candidates who later win awards for top scores regularly say they thought they had failed.
What Rachael Would Tell You Now
Is another attempt worth it? Rachael’s answer is unequivocal: “It’s always worth it.” Whether your path has been a two-year sprint or a five-to-six-year marathon while working and raising a family, you’ve made it this far.
On her third attempt, Rachael didn’t just scrape through. She passed on every level, including the areas that had held her back before. And the journey gave her something a first-time pass wouldn’t have: it put her imposter syndrome to rest. After a 20-year finance career and a return to accounting as a mature student, she knows she earned it. “It is mine now, and I conquered it. You can too.”
It’s hard to hear an unsuccessful result, and we’d never take that away from anyone. But the resilience and grit you build working through something difficult are qualities that stay with you long after the exam.
Preparing for Your Next CFE Attempt?
If you’re planning to rewrite, this conversation will help you think carefully about your results, your study approach, and what needs to change before your next attempt.
Watch the full video with Rachael and learn more about our CPA CFE preparation resources at gevorgcpa.com.


