Passing the CFE on Your Third Attempt: What Rachael Learned After Two Close Calls

If you’ve been unsuccessful on the CPA Common Final Examination (CFE), you’re in far more common company than most people realize. Having coached CPA candidates for years, we’ve seen just how many different paths lead to the Canadian CPA designation, and plenty of them include more than one CFE attempt.

That’s why we sat down again with GCPA alum Rachael, who passed the CFE on her third and final attempt. What makes her story valuable isn’t the unsuccessful results. It’s how she worked through them, adjusted her approach, and kept going.

Watch the full conversation on YouTube

Rachael’s CFE Timeline

  • Attempt 1 (May): Unsuccessful, Decile 1. She did not clear Level 3 (depth in her role, Assurance) and also fell short on Management Accounting at Level 2.
  • Attempt 2 (September, immediately after): Unsuccessful again, Decile 1, this time on Level 1. By her own estimate, she was one or two questions away.
  • Attempt 3: Registered for May, then chose to defer to September. She passed, and cleared every area.

Two Decile 1 results in a row. As Rachael put it, it felt like “a cruel, cruel lesson.” But it wasn’t the end of her story.

Coming Close Twice

Rachael received her first results while on a family vacation. She gave herself time to feel it, then decided to go straight into the September rewrite with a focused sprint: review what she knew, dig deeper into Assurance, and tighten up her time management.

The second result, arriving just before Christmas, hit differently. “It felt like pure exhaustion,” she shared. She had gone in with hope and a “what’s the worst that could happen?” mindset, and then it felt like the worst had happened.

Her takeaway, and the one she most wants other candidates to hear: there is no direct line and no perfect journey. You take each thing as it comes.

You Don’t Have to Relearn Everything

When Rachael restarted in February, she felt lost. Should she redo everything? Did she really know anything at all?

The answer was no, she didn’t need to redo everything. Looking at the stacks of cases, Integrations, and Practice Cases from her earlier attempts, she realized that what actually needed restudying was much smaller than it looked. “It’s more going to be the mind game and the time game,” she said. The real work was deciding what to review and how.

Knowing When to Wait

After studying through the spring for a May rewrite, Rachael made the difficult decision to defer. She had been doing all the right things, but she was mentally exhausted. Work was heavy following a major ERP implementation, and when she told her family she was stepping back, their response was simple: they had seen it too, and they supported her.

Today, the CFE is offered only in September, so candidates rewriting will have a longer runway by default. Rachael’s advice for using that time well:

  • Build up gradually. Push through spring and summer, then start easing off in August.
  • Protect the final 10 days. Before the exam, shift to light review only: notes, cue cards, good sleep, and whatever helps you decompress. Even if you’re working until the week of the exam, find a way to shift gears mentally.
  • Trust that you won’t forget. Many candidates worry that slowing down means losing ground. Rachael found the opposite. That breathing room is what let her walk in with the mental capacity to perform.

What Rachael Did Differently the Third Time

Better pacing. On her first attempt, she tried to do too much, including writing three Day 3 cases back to back to simulate exam day. By the third attempt, she recognized that she already knew she could sit for five hours and work through roughly 21 Assessment Opportunities across three cases. She didn’t need to prove that to herself again.

Trusting what she knew. A first-time writer often walks in wondering whether they know anything. A rewriter has results that show exactly what they do and don’t know. “The idea of going into Day 3 and knowing nothing is just not the truth,” Rachael said.

Working with a coach who fit her needs. Rachael worked with Mallory, a coach she found through Gevorg CPA, throughout her program. For Rachael, Mallory was an accountability partner and someone to share her thoughts, fears, and frustrations with. Other candidates may need a tougher, more directive style. Her advice is to find the right fit, much like choosing a therapist, and to remember that coaching doesn’t have to be a six-month commitment. A handful of sessions over the summer can help you refine your approach.

Taking accommodations seriously. Rachael shared that she could have applied for exam accommodations and chose not to, and looking back, she wishes she had. With only September sittings, a first-time rewrite no longer leaves you without time to apply. If you need an accommodation, plan ahead and apply. No one else needs to know, and you deserve every chance of success.

Don’t Just Repeat the Same Preparation

If you do the same thing again, how can you expect a different result? Before rewriting, be honest with yourself:

  • Did you follow your study schedule?
  • Did you have an accountability partner, study buddy, or study network?
  • Were your time management and case strategy working?

At the same time, avoid over-rotating. Failing in one area doesn’t mean you should study only that area. You still need coverage everywhere, with extra focus where your results point.

Read Your Results Carefully

Rachael’s first results surprised her. With a background in audit and risk, she expected Assurance to come easily. With years in finance, she assumed Management Accounting would make intuitive business sense. Instead, she did better in Financial Reporting than in either. Her lesson: set aside your assumptions about which areas are “easy” for you, and look at what the numbers actually say.

Equally important, the areas you passed were not luck. “Your passes were not luck. You did what you needed to do,” Rachael said.

The CFE passing profile is publicly available, but it isn’t simple. Unlike a university exam with a single percentage, the CFE is assessed across four levels, and candidates often misread them. For example:

  • Passing Level 4 (breadth) does not mean you passed Day 3.
  • Passing Level 3 (depth in your role) does not mean you passed Day 2.

Misinterpreting your results can send your preparation in the wrong direction. Take the time to understand them properly, whether with us, a mentor, or another trusted resource, before you build your rewrite plan.

And a word on online forums: be careful with Reddit threads. People aren’t necessarily lying, but they are sharing their own perception, often without the full picture. Candidates who later win awards for top scores regularly say they thought they had failed.

What Rachael Would Tell You Now

Is another attempt worth it? Rachael’s answer is unequivocal: “It’s always worth it.” Whether your path has been a two-year sprint or a five-to-six-year marathon while working and raising a family, you’ve made it this far.

On her third attempt, Rachael didn’t just scrape through. She passed on every level, including the areas that had held her back before. And the journey gave her something a first-time pass wouldn’t have: it put her imposter syndrome to rest. After a 20-year finance career and a return to accounting as a mature student, she knows she earned it. “It is mine now, and I conquered it. You can too.”

It’s hard to hear an unsuccessful result, and we’d never take that away from anyone. But the resilience and grit you build working through something difficult are qualities that stay with you long after the exam.

Preparing for Your Next CFE Attempt?

If you’re planning to rewrite, this conversation will help you think carefully about your results, your study approach, and what needs to change before your next attempt.

Watch the full video with Rachael and learn more about our CPA CFE preparation resources at gevorgcpa.com.

The Final 7 Days Before the CPA CFE: Gevorg CPA Memo to CFE Writers

Since all of you reading this are already deep in CFE mode, we thought we’d make this blog more digestible for you by writing it as a CFE memo. Please enjoy. And for any of you who are reading this in panic mode, from the GCPA team, we believe in you, you can do this, and we wish you nothing but the best!

To: CFE Candidates

From: Gevorg CPA Team

Date: September 8, 2026

Re: How to approach the final seven days before the CFE

Purpose

In the last week before every CFE, the GCPA team receives a similar version of the following question from our students: what should I actually be doing right now? This memo will provide context and insight into what your final days of preparation should, and sometimes more importantly, should not include.

Scope and assumptions

We have assumed the following. If any of these do not hold, the advice below will not fit your situation.

  1. You are writing all three days of the CFE.
  2. You have prepared consistently. You worked through PEP, completed Capstone 1 and Capstone 2, and you have written and debriefed cases over a period of months. Your preparation is substantially complete.
  3. You are not starting from zero. If you began studying a week or two ago, this memo does not apply to you. Your priorities in the next seven days are different from the ones described here.
  4. We count the final week backwards, so “seven days out” means one week before you write. When we refer to Day 1, Day 2, and Day 3, we mean the three days of the exam itself.

Analysis

Your exam fitness is already built, the final week can’t build more

Preparing for the CFE is a marathon. Your ability to read a case, rank the AOs, and write with the right balance of depth and breadth was not built in a week, and cannot be built in a week. It was built slowly, over months of technical work, repeated case writing, and feedback. No runner builds their fitness in the seven days before a race, and no candidate builds case-writing ability in the seven days before the CFE.

That has a consequence people tend to skip past. If the fitness is already built, the final week cannot meaningfully add to it. That said, there are two things that can happen in the final week. The first is supporting your head space or mental fortitude to challenge the exam. And the second, is over-working and over studying that ultimately fatigues you to the point of hurting your exam performance.

The first thing: protecting your head space

Head space is not a soft concept on this exam. It is the difference between reading a required and trusting your first read, or reading it four times and still not committing. It is the difference between ranking your AOs and moving, or second-guessing the ranking until you have burned twenty minutes you needed at the end. Confidence shows up as decisiveness, and decisiveness is what protects your time.

So the test for any activity this week is simple. Does this make me more settled, or less? Rereading your own debrief notes and seeing how much you have fixed since May does. A brand new question bank four days out does not, and neither does the group chat where everyone is announcing how many cases they have written. This is not the week to go looking for hard truths, because there is no longer time to act on them.

The second thing: over-working yourself into a worse result

The other thing that can happen this week is that you quietly spend the capacity you are going to need. This one is hard to see, because studying feels virtuous. Nobody feels guilty at hour ten, and the cost does not show up until the exam room.

The clearest version is the candidate who writes a full case three days out, performs poorly because they are already tired, and walks into Day 1 shaken. That result told them nothing useful, because what they measured was a depleted version of themselves. The quieter version is studying twelve hours a day right through to the night before and arriving on Day 1 already spent, performing several notches below what they are actually capable of.

Why fatigue shows up where it does

Treat your brain the way a runner treats their legs in the final week. It is a muscle, it has been under load for months, and it is not fresh. Capstone 2 drew it down, and the exam is going to ask you to hold up across three consecutive writing days, not one.

Fatigue also does not announce itself as feeling tired. It shows up as degraded judgement. You rank your AOs more slowly and keep revisiting the ranking. You write more, but shallower, because you are not confident enough to commit. You misread an AO required and catch it on the last page. You run out of time on the final case of Day 3. None of that is a knowledge failure. It is a capacity failure, and capacity is the one thing this week can genuinely change, in either direction.

What is still worth working on

To be clear, we are not telling you to do nothing for seven days. We are telling you to be honest about what seven days can actually move.

Not movable now: technical depth in an area you never learned properly, comfort with a competency you have avoided all year, or a real gap in your understanding of a standard. Going after these now costs energy and returns very little, and it tends to produce panic rather than knowledge.

Still worth your time now:

  • Debriefing. If you have cases sitting un-debriefed, that is the highest value work available to you this week. The learning on this exam happens in the debrief, not in the writing, and a proper debrief of a case you already wrote costs a fraction of the energy of writing a new one.
  • Thinking through and visualizing your approach. Walk yourself through how you open a case, how you rank the AOs, when you start writing, and what you do when a required runs long. You are rehearsing a routine you already have, not building a new one. This is the single cheapest way to arrive on Day 1 feeling like you know what you are doing.
  • Reminding yourself of high level concepts. Frameworks, decision points, the shape of a good analysis in each of the competency areas. Stay at altitude. This is not the week for paragraph 5 of a standard.
  • Reviewing generally through your own notes. Your summaries, your debrief notes, your Capstone 1 material. The point is familiarity and reassurance, not new coverage. You will be surprised how much you have absorbed since May, and noticing that is genuinely useful right now.
  • Taking care of yourself. Sleep properly. Eat real meals at normal times. Go for walks, ideally outside and without your phone. Have a few intentional conversations with people who are not writing the CFE and who will talk to you about something else. Move your body a little.

We want to be clear that the last one is not filler at the end of the list. Rest, food, movement, and human contact are what rebuild the capacity you are going to spend across three writing days, and they are what keep your head space steady while you wait. An hour of walking outside will do more for your Day 1 performance than an hour of rereading a standard you already know. That trade feels wrong, which is exactly why so few candidates make it.

Notice what everything on this list has in common. It is consolidation and recovery, not acquisition. Habits, familiarity, and capacity respond to light work in a week. Knowledge does not.

Recommendation

Taper. Bring your volume down deliberately over the next seven days so that your capacity comes back up and your head space stays intact. Front-load anything demanding into the first two days of the week, spend the middle on light targeted review, and use the final two days for logistics and rest.

Frequently asked questions

What should I study during the final week before the CFE?

Review your own debrief notes, your recurring weak habits, and your case approach, and refresh your Capstone 1 material. Practise finding guidance quickly rather than reading it deeply. Do not start new technical topics or new study materials in the final week, since there is no longer enough time for new knowledge to become usable under exam conditions.

Should I write full cases in the last few days?

No. Write your last full case around six or seven days out, then stop. Writing a full case within three days of the exam is a poor use of limited energy, and a weak result on a tired practice attempt tends to damage your confidence without telling you anything you can act on in time.

When should I stop studying before exam day?

Stop by midday the day before you write. A short, light review in the morning is fine. After that, the cost to your clarity on Day 1 outweighs anything you would gain. Use the rest of the day for packing, logistics, and rest.

What should I prepare for CFE exam day?

Confirm your writing location, start time, and arrival window. Plan your route with a buffer. Set aside your identification and only the permitted items. Complete any required hardware or software checks in advance. Pack layers for a cold room, along with food and water. Verify every requirement against the current instructions from CPA Canada and your regional body, since these vary by cycle and location.

How can I sleep better the night before the CFE, and does it really matter?

Honestly, you are probably not going to sleep well the night before, and that is fine. Almost nobody does, and you have already worked and studied on very little sleep plenty of times. Bank your sleep in the week beforehand, when you can actually control it, then stop worrying about the last night. Keep your usual bedtime rather than getting into bed unusually early, stop studying by midday, get some daylight and light movement, and keep screens and the group chat out of the last hour. Have everything packed and your alarms set so nothing is unresolved. If you lie awake anyway, accept it and move on.

 

Why Accountants Fail the CFE (And How You Can Pass Before 2027 Changes)

 

The CFE pass rate hovers around 70%. In 2024 specifically, it was 67%. This means that every year, roughly one in three candidates opens their results to bad news.

It is unfortunate to see. At Gevorg CPA, we have seen brilliant students—accountants who are stars at their firms and who studied for months—fail to clear the hurdle.

The stakes are higher than ever right now. There are only 4 CFEs left in the current program. If you don’t clear the exam in these remaining sittings, you risk having to switch to the new certification program, which brings uncertainty and new requirements. You need to get this right now.

Why do students fail? The truth is, you don’t fail the CFE because you aren’t smart enough. You fail because you didn’t play the “game” correctly. Based on years of interacting with thousands of students and analyzing unsuccessful attempts, we have found that failure almost always boils down to 4 specific mistakes.

Reason 1: Weak or Mismanaged Technicals

There are two primary ways students mismanage their technical study:

  1. The Crammer: This student tries to read everything. They burn valuable study time memorizing obscure paragraphs of the Handbook that are unlikely to be tested. The result is often burnout and a lack of focus on the basics.
  2. The Gambler: Skips “hard” topics like Tax or Finance, hoping they won’t appear.

You need “Competence,” not perfection. Focus on commonly tested topics like Revenue Recognition, Contingencies, and Inventory. For complex niche topics, you just need enough knowledge to put something reasonable on paper to avoid an “NC” (Nominal Competence). Don’t fully skip “hard” topics, but scratch the surface, make sure you know something about everything, even the basics. For example, hedging means to protect yourself, there are: forwards, futures, options, swaps. Forwards and futures are agreements to buy or sell something at a specific price later on. Options give businesses the choice, but not the obligation, to make a trade at certain price. Swaps are deals where companies exchange cash with each other. That’s all you need to know for hedging to “pass” (unless Finance is your depth area)! You can provide simplified summaries like this for all topics in new Gevorg CPA Simple Study Notes. 

Reason 2: Poor Case Writing Skills

CFE is unique. If you write long, unstructured essays, the marker—who can only allocate about 2-3 minutes grading your AO—will miss your points. You must make it easy for them to find the right answers.

  • Structure: Stick to “The CPA Way” (Issue, Analysis, Recommendation) for most issues. Specific topics, like audit control deficiencies, require their own structures like “WIR”. We provide such “templates” to students in our exam preparation programs.
  • Case Facts (The “Why”): This is the single most important skill. You must focus on applying case facts, because that is the “why.” This is how the marker knows that you are competent. Stating the technical rule is not enough, you must link it to the facts to get the top marks.
  • Typing Speed: If you are under 45 WPM, you are likely to struggle on time. Aim for 50-80 WPM.
  • CFE Day 1 Fatal Flaw: You must consider the interrelationship of the issues. You cannot analyze issues in isolation; they must connect back to the big picture.

Reason 3: Not Understanding the “Levels” of Passing

In CPA Canada CFE, you aren’t given a percentage grade. You must pass 4 distinct levels (Sufficiency, Depth in FR/MA, Depth in Role, and Breadth). Understanding this passing profile is critical for two reasons:

  1. Study Strategy (Preparation Phase) Knowing the levels dictates where you spend your time. If your role is Assurance (Level 3), you must be an expert there. Do not spend 80% of your time studying Tax if you only need “Breadth” (Level 4) in Tax. Allocate your study hours according to the depth required.
  2. Exam Day Strategy (Execution Phase) Use this knowledge to prioritize mid-exam. If you are running out of time on Day 2 and have two AOs left—one in your Role and one in Finance—you must know which one to prioritize. You must pass your Role (Level 3), so write that one fully. You only need Breadth (Level 4) in Finance, so you can afford to write less there. This mid-exam adjustment often separates the passes from the fails.

Reason 4: The Time Trap

Board of Examiners design cases to test your ability to prioritize under pressure. If you spend 25 minutes on a hard AO, you sacrifice the easy marks at the end of the case.

Use a strict Time Budget. If your timer goes off, stop writing. An imperfect answer gets you a pass (RC); an empty answer gets you a zero.

How to Clear the Exam

  1. Debriefing is King: Debriefing means comparing your answer to the solution and learning from your mistakes. Figure out exactly why you missed an indicator.
  2. Master the Unfamiliar: Use “General Logic” for topics you’ve never seen. Apply case facts to pros/cons to squeeze out an RC.
  3. Build a Consistent Study Plan: Consistency beats intensity. Build a study plan that fits your life, whether you are a morning person or a night owl.

We have a ton of free resources on our website to help you master these strategies. However, if you want full support, our programs have resources to cover off all these challenging areas. Our program and platform will guide you through the process to ensure you’re ready for this exam and know all the strategies you need to clear the CFE.

Check out the Gevorg, CPA CFE exam coaching programs and learn how to pass. Our comprehensive courses cover every stage of the CPA CFE process, ensuring you’re fully prepared. With a proven track record of helping over 4,500 students succeed, you can be next.